For physicians, dietitians, nurses, counselors, and lifestyle educators
Other guides in this series:
Stephanie is scrolling on Amazon over her lunch break. She types “reverse insulin resistance” into the search box, and two books come up on the first page of results.
The first is called Understanding Metabolic Dysfunction: A Comprehensive Guide. She reads the title and keeps scrolling. If Stephanie had clicked on “Read sample,” she would have been met with more jargon and more information without story or promise.
The second has a subtitle with strong action words making Stephanie a promise: Reclaim Your Energy in Ninety Days! She clicks Read sample. Chapter one begins with a woman named Ruth, fifty-eight, who could not get through a grocery store without sitting down on the bench by the pharmacy, and who had decided, in the car outside the store, that this was simply what fifty-eight felt like. Stephanie’s lunch break is half over. After page three, she clicks “Add to Cart.”
Same woman. Same problem. Same information inside both books. One of the books sold. One didn’t.
This page is about writing the second book. It draws on the best books ever written on story, because a health book succeeds or fails on the same thing a novel does: whether the reader keeps turning pages, and whether what she reads changes what she does on Tuesday. Here’s what we’ve learned.
The reader is the hero of your book
A health book has two candidate heroes, the patient in the case story and the reader. The reader is the one on the hero’s journey. The patients are encouragers. The patients arrive, add courage and hope, and show the reader what the road ahead is like. Then they leave. The reader is the one who’s supposed to be different on the last page, so the book is about the reader’s story, and every chapter brings the reader closer to total transformation.
She arrives on page one wanting something: a chest that does not tighten on the stairs, lungs that fill all the way, restful sleep, peace from the fear of a heart attack. And she arrives already believing something that keeps her from getting it. “This is what fifty-eight feels like.” “My body is permanently damaged.” “Pain is my new normal.” “I’ve tried everything.”
In a story, that limiting false belief is what K. M. Weiland calls the character’s Lie and what Lisa Cron calls the misbelief: the thing the hero is sure of at the start that the story will prove wrong.1 Name your reader’s misbelief in one sentence. Then order your chapters as the journey from that belief to the truth, each chapter’s conclusion forcing the next chapter’s question. The book ends with the reader acting, not with the author’s credentials.
One distinction keeps this frame honest. The misbelief is always about what can change: “nothing can be done,” “my choices no longer matter,” “this is just aging.” Those beliefs are the book’s rightful target, and overturning them is the best news a reader can get. The misbelief is never the cause of the disease. A book that says, or implies, “your cancer came from your thinking” or “your diabetes is your lack of faith” has stopped helping and started blaming, and the reader who needed you most closes your book.
Say the outcome, and say it first
People do not buy health books for information. They buy them for the result. Blake Snyder’s test for a movie pitch is whether the title and the one-line description tell you what you are going to get, and he is blunt about the alternative: “Advice like: ‘Follow your heart!’ and ‘Be true to your vision!’ is fine if you’re in therapy.”2 In the marketplace, the reader wants to know what she will have when she is done.
So write the one-sentence promise before you write anything else. “What if the standard advice for X is backward?” “What if a reader could reverse Y in ninety days with Z?” That sentence is your title, your back cover, and the test every chapter must pass. For medical and lifestyle books we have found that an action verb outsells a description: “Reclaim” outsells “Reclaiming.” Also, a medical subtitle can run to fifteen or eighteen words when it focuses on promised outcomes.
Then be honest about it. The promise must match the evidence. The craft principle and the medical principle agree here, and our editors hold both lines.
Open with a person and a problem, never with a definition
Readers hunt for three things on page one, according to Cron: whose story is it, what is happening, and what is at stake.3 A definition answers none of them. Ruth on the pharmacy bench answers all three.
Every chapter, not only the first, should open with something at stake for a specific person. Snyder has a name for the alternative, the chapter that spends its first pages explaining before anything happens: Laying Pipe.4 Readers can feel pipe being laid, and they leave.
The same rule says: do not open with the cure. The payoff means nothing to a reader who has not been brought into the world where the problem lives. Jesus did not open the parable of the prodigal son with the robe and the ring. He gave the far country first, the famine, the pigs, and a hungry man who “was longing to be fed with the pods that the pigs ate” (Luke 15:16). Only then “the best robe,” the ring, and the shoes (Luke 15:22), and by then every listener wanted them for him. Show the good life before the diagnosis, so the loss registers. Then the reader will want what you have to give.
Every case story is a short story, and most of them have no middle
“She followed the plan and improved.”
Most case stories in health manuscripts are that one sentence stretched to a page, and that is why they persuade no one. It has a beginning and an end and nothing in between. No resistance. No relapse. No night the patient ate the whole pan. No moment she decided, against her own habit, to try once more. A case story without a middle reads as an advertisement, and readers have learned to skip advertisements.
A case story is a short story. It needs a picture of the before, a clear stake, a commitment, a crisis, and a result. One patient per case. One teaching point per case. Enter at the moment that matters, reveal the outcome late, and leave at the peak. The inner change (the denial that cracked, the fear that was finally named) comes before the outer result, which is what makes cases persuasive rather than merely illustrative.
And put the relapse in. Donald Maass, who has spent thirty years as a literary agent reading what makes readers care, says it in one line: “The emotional impact of change lies less in the change itself and more in resistance to it.”5 A patient who accepts the truth on first hearing gives the reader nothing. A patient who tried the crash diet, lost the weight, gained it back, and came in anyway is the reader.
Snyder has a rule for how such a story must end. He calls it Out of the Bottle: when a hero is given magic, the hero must learn, by the end, to do it without the magic.6 For a health book that means the ending is a lifestyle, not a pill or a single food. Any chapter that promises a wish-fulfillment result gets rewritten.
Deliver the physiology while something is happening
The central craft problem of a health book is exposition. The reader needs to understand the mechanism. How much, and when?
Jack Hart, who edited narrative nonfiction at The Oregonian for years, states the problem without softening it: “Exposition—the backstory readers need to understand what’s going on—is the enemy of narrative.” His remedy comes from the veteran feature writer Bill Blundell, who called it the sandwich technique: “Action’s the bread. Exposition’s the filling.”7 Every stretch of physiology in your book needs bread on both sides of it: a patient’s question, a kitchen, a surprising setting, a decision that cannot be made until the reader understands the mechanism.
Hart also gives the structure a health book usually needs. He calls it the explanatory narrative, and his model follows a batch of french fries from the potato field to the fryer. The action line is only a spine; the digressions carry the explanation, and each one leaves the action at a point of suspense so the reader follows it back.8 One patient’s year, one family’s table, one meal’s path through the body can be the spine of a whole book, with the medicine in the digressions.
And ask of every paragraph the two-word question Cron asks: “And so?”9 Donald Maass states the same test from the other side: “Dry information is only dry when it doesn’t mean anything to anyone.”10 A reader in the grip of a question does not want the third study confirming a point already made. One best-selling author’s rule is that research belongs in the back story,11 which for you means mentioning the study after the story or moving the research to an endnote.
Here’s what that looks like when it’s done well. In The Creator’s Code, Dr. James Marcum has a chapter on water. He does not open it with the research. He opens it with Sandy, who came to his office with fatigue, muscle cramps, trouble concentrating, and a heart beating irregularly at around ninety beats a minute at rest. The tests found nothing. He noticed her skin was dry, ordered a urine test, found it abnormally concentrated, and wrote the whole prescription in one line: ninety ounces of water a day. Ten days later the cramps, the fog, and the irregular heartbeat were gone. Only then does he bring in the study, one study, from the American Journal of Epidemiology: five glasses of water a day cut the risk of dying from heart disease in half compared with fewer than two.12 The citation sits in his endnotes, where the physician who wants to check it can find it in thirty seconds. The reader who wants to feel like Sandy felt on day ten never breaks stride.
Show the symptom, then show why
Here is a rule that will feel wrong to a clinician and is right anyway. Physical description alone does not carry emotion. Angela Ackerman and Becca Puglisi, authors of The Emotion Thesaurus, state it as a rule: “Physical reactions show what emotion is present, and the thoughts show why it’s there. Both must be included for it all to make sense.”13 Fidgety fingers could be dread or excitement. The reader needs the cause, and the cause arrives through the patient’s thought or words.
They also explain why a patient’s inner voice almost never names the feeling: “An excited person doesn’t think to himself, I’m so excited! because he already knows it. Instead, he thinks about the cause.”14 So does a frightened one. “She was frustrated with her diet” is a label. “She stood in the pantry with the door open, not hungry, reading the back of a cereal box she had read a hundred times” is a person. One body cue plus one thought gives the reader the patient’s why.
Cron’s formula is the one to tape to your monitor: “Don’t tell me John is sad, show me why he’s sad.”15 Swap “sad” for “noncompliant” and you have the whole art of the case story.
Keep it proportionate. A book that dramatizes every case at full volume becomes melodrama, and melodrama costs you the one thing a medical author cannot afford to lose, which is credibility. The stock phrases of the genre, “devastating diagnosis,” “overwhelming relief,” are the health-book form of what Mary Karr calls sentimentality: “emotion without vivid evidence.”16
The actual food, the actual dose, the actual number
Natalie Goldberg’s instruction to writers is “Give things the dignity of their names,”17 and she goes on: “Learn the names of everything: birds, cheese, tractors, cars, buildings.”18 For you that means nutrients, foods, organs, drugs. Not “many people find” but one patient. Not “a healthy breakfast” but the actual plate. Not “her numbers improved” but the A1c, before and after.
Luke, the physician among the Gospel writers, reports a case exactly this way. Not “a chronically ill woman” but “a woman who had had a discharge of blood for twelve years, and though she had spent all her living on physicians, she could not be healed by anyone,” who “touched the fringe of his garment, and immediately her discharge of blood ceased” (Luke 8:43-44). Twelve years. All her living. The fringe of the garment. Immediately. A few exact particulars beat a page of adjectives. Give each case story one concrete, slightly surprising detail (the pill organizer with Tuesday still full) and the reader builds the rest.
George Orwell’s test for any figure of speech is whether the writer is actually seeing the thing it describes. His exhibit was a line from a political pamphlet in which “the Fascist octopus has sung its swan song,” an octopus and a swan in one sentence, which proves the writer saw neither.19 Health writers depend on metaphor for mechanism: the artery as a pipe, insulin as a key. Picture each one literally. If the picture collapses or needs a footnote, cut it.
Write like a person, not a journal article
Medical prose defaults to the agentless passive. “It has been shown.” “It is believed.” “Mistakes were made.” One best-selling author’s rule is the single biggest improvement available to most physician-authors: “The adverb is not your friend,”20 and the passive is worse. The liver processes; there is not “processing in the liver.” When your blood sugar drops, you feel shaky; cause before effect.
The didactic forms of the adverb problem are “extremely important,” “absolutely essential,” “clearly shows.” Each one tells the reader you doubted the sentence could stand alone. Cut them and the sentence stands. Cron’s version: “The bigger the word, the less emotion it conveys.”21
Then cut again. One author’s pacing rule, borrowed from the novelist Elmore Leonard, is the shortest in the craft literature: leave out the boring parts.22 Solomon again, and he was not joking: “Of making many books there is no end, and much study is a weariness of the flesh” (Ecclesiastes 12:12). Your reader is already weary. A 400-page health book with ninety sections is trying to say everything, and Snyder’s judgment on that is blunt: if you need fifty of something, you have a problem.23 One principle, one case, one practice per chapter. The health book that tries to say everything says nothing. Ellen White told her own writers the same in 1871, and the sentence has not aged: “Brevity should be studied in order to interest the reader. Long, wordy articles are an injury to the truth which the writer aims to present.”24
Be good company
The physician who sneers at the overweight, the addicted, the noncompliant loses the reader on the first sneer. Lamott’s standard for every narrator applies with double force to a doctor: candor, hope, clear sight, and no contempt. Maass adds that readers are pulled through a book by hope, not by fear, and that fear-driven persuasion is not hope.25 Name the stakes honestly, make the danger real and near, and then give the reader somewhere to go.
Solomon had the physician-author’s standard three thousand years early: “Gracious words are like a honeycomb, sweetness to the soul and health to the body” (Proverbs 16:24). The voice is part of the medicine.
The oldest version of the rule is in the first chapter of Mark. Before a single parable, a leper comes. “Moved with pity, he stretched out his hand and touched him” (Mark 1:41). One small, specific act, the touch no one else would give, and every reader is on his side for the rest of the book. Blake Snyder’s name for that moment is Save the Cat.26 Your save-the-cat moment is not your CV. It is one real thing you did for one real patient, on the first pages, that shows the reader who she is about to spend three hundred pages with.
And let the reader see that you changed too. How you came to this knowledge, what you believed before, the patient who taught you: that is the story a reader trusts, and it belongs early.
Truth outranks drama
Every craft principle on this page has one limit, and it is our standard, not the craft books’. Case stories must be true, de-identified, consented, and not improved. A composite is labeled a composite. The resolution of a case must match the real outcome. “Raise the stakes” never means inflate a claim. Any medical claim that needs a source, a qualification, or a disclaimer is flagged, not asserted, and no narrative technique may make a claim more persuasive than the evidence allows. When a manuscript calls for it, a medical doctor or a dietitian joins the editorial team to hold that line.
The pattern is an old one. Peter set the standard for every witness who writes: “we did not follow cleverly devised myths when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but we were eyewitnesses of his majesty” (2 Peter 1:16). A case story that has been improved is a cleverly devised myth with a diagnosis attached.
Before you send it
- Can I say in one sentence what the reader will be able to do, or stop doing, when she finishes?
- Does chapter one open with a person and a problem, not a credential, a definition, or the cure?
- Does every case story have a middle: a crisis, a relapse, a decision?
- Is every stretch of physiology riding on a question the reader is already asking?
- Where have I named a feeling instead of showing its cause?
- Have I replaced “many people find” with one patient, one plate, one number?
- Have I cut the passives, the intensifiers, and ten percent of the words?
- Does the reader see me change, and see me act kindly, before she sees my credentials?
- Does every claim match its evidence?
This is the shape our editors read for. When a case has no middle, we do not invent one; we ask you for the real one.
At TEACH Services, three editors and three designers put their efforts and skills into every manuscript in our Professional, Advanced, and Premium packages, with a physician or dietitian added when the subject calls for one. It is why Dr. James Marcum’s The Creator’s Code reached #1 New Release in Amazon’s Naturopathy category, and why 60% of the books in those packages sell more than 150 copies, four times the rate for self-published books (the full table is on our Writer’s Tips and Guidelines page).
Sources
Lisa Cron, Wired for Story (2012). Donald Maass, The Emotional Craft of Fiction (2016). Angela Ackerman and Becca Puglisi, The Emotion Thesaurus (2nd ed., 2019). Jack Hart, Storycraft (2nd ed., 2021). Stephen King, On Writing (2000). Blake Snyder, Save the Cat! (2005). They were written for novelists and screenwriters. Read them for how a reader’s attention works, which is the same whether what she is reading about is a detective or her own pancreas. For questions of style, usage, and the handling of Scripture references, the standard desk reference is Robert Hudson, The Christian Writer’s Manual of Style, 4th ed. (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2016).
Unfortunately, not all the authors in this list are Christians, and some objectionable language or ideas are found in certain parts of the books in this list. We list them here because Christian authors need to become better writers, but there is a shortage of books by good Christian authors that teach good writing. One author we can recommend wholeheartedly is K. M. Weiland. She is a Christian author, and her books on story arc and character arc have been in the top sellers’ lists for years because they’re that good.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.
Mike Brazington, Publisher
Notes and sources
- K. M. Weiland, Creating Character Arcs: The Masterful Author’s Guide to Uniting Story Structure, Plot, and Character Development (Scottsbluff, NE: PenForASword Publishing, 2016), part 1; Lisa Cron, Story Genius: How to Use Brain Science to Go Beyond Outlining and Write a Riveting Novel (Berkeley, CA: Ten Speed Press, 2016), chap. 3. ↩
- Blake Snyder, Save the Cat! The Last Book on Screenwriting You’ll Ever Need (Studio City, CA: Michael Wiese Productions, 2005), xiii. ↩
- Lisa Cron, Wired for Story: The Writer’s Guide to Using Brain Science to Hook Readers from the Very First Sentence (Berkeley, CA: Ten Speed Press, 2012), chap. 1. ↩
- Snyder, Save the Cat!, chap. 6. ↩
- Donald Maass, The Emotional Craft of Fiction: How to Write the Story Beneath the Surface (Cincinnati: Writer’s Digest Books, 2016), chap. 3. ↩
- Snyder, Save the Cat!, chap. 6. ↩
- Jack Hart, Storycraft: The Complete Guide to Writing Narrative Nonfiction, 2nd ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2021). ↩
- Hart, Storycraft, chap. 16. ↩
- Cron, Wired for Story, chap. 1. ↩
- Maass, Emotional Craft of Fiction, 62. ↩
- Stephen King, On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft (New York: Scribner, 2000), “On Writing.” ↩
- James L. Marcum, The Creator’s Code (Calhoun, GA: TEACH Services, 2026), chap. 6, “Healing Action #2: Drink More Water.” ↩
- Angela Ackerman and Becca Puglisi, The Emotion Thesaurus: A Writer’s Guide to Character Expression, 2nd ed. (JADD Publishing, 2019), “Over-Reliance on Body Language.” ↩
- Ackerman and Puglisi, Emotion Thesaurus, “Common Problems with Writing Nonverbal Emotion.” ↩
- Cron, Wired for Story, chap. 8. ↩
- Mary Karr, The Art of Memoir (New York: Harper, 2015), 68. ↩
- Natalie Goldberg, Writing Down the Bones: Freeing the Writer Within, 30th anniversary ed. (Boston: Shambhala, 2016), “Be Specific.” ↩
- Goldberg, Writing Down the Bones, “Be Specific.” ↩
- George Orwell, “Politics and the English Language,” Horizon 13, no. 76 (April 1946): 252–65. ↩
- King, On Writing, “Toolbox.” ↩
- Cron, Wired for Story, chap. 3. ↩
- King, On Writing, “On Writing.” ↩
- Snyder, Save the Cat!, chap. 5. ↩
- Ellen G. White, Testimonies for the Church, vol. 2 (Mountain View, CA: Pacific Press Publishing Association, 1871), 671. ↩
- Maass, Emotional Craft of Fiction, chap. 7. ↩
- Snyder, Save the Cat!, introduction. ↩